Add this one to the long list of scandals involving altered news photos: World Press Photo disqualified the third prize winner of the contest's Sports Features category for removing an extraneous foot from an image.
Stepan Rudik's story about street fighting in Kiev, Ukraine included a close-up image of someone's hand being bandaged (first image shown here). Removed from the original image (second image shown) was a small, blurry white sneaker that belonged to a person standing in the background.

WPP organizers said on their Web site that after the contest results were announced, it came to their attention "that Rudik's story had violated a contest rule. After requesting RAW-files of the series from him, it became clear that an element had been removed from one of the original photographs."
Bill Frakes, a WPP juror, explained to PDN: "The jury felt that this was not acceptable. Not in line with industry standards which is the test."
I don't argue that the profession has to draw its lines in the sand. Various bloggers have reported the controversy, and Rudik has been taken to task. It's a public ritual by which examples are made of people--previously Brian Walski, Patrick Schneider, Allan Detrich, and Edgar Martins, to name several--and standards are maintained.
But I have to confess that I don't entirely understand the arbitrary rules and the lack of proportionality. It's as if littering were as bad as armed robbery, and murder OK depending upon the weapon.
In Rudik's case, for instance, he was disqualified for removing the smallest element, but I would argue that all his other manipulation to the image in question did much more to change the meaning. And it was all acceptable, apparently. He converted a color image to black and white. He blew the image up. He cropped the image. He vignetted it heavily. Burning out the sneaker in a darkroom probably would have been OK back in the day, when photographers did that all the time. But removing that sneaker in Photoshop? That was a cardinal sin, and some famous burn-and-dodgers of yore are now said to be spinning in their graves.
Related photo doctoring stories:
Brian Walski was fired by the Los Angeles Times in 2003 for altering an Iraq war photo.
Patrick Schneider was stripped of POY awards in 2003 and was fired by the Charlotte Observer after a second offense in 2006.
Allan Detrich resigned from the Toledo Blade in 2007 after he was caught doctoring numerous photos.
Edgar Martins embarrassed The New York Times last summer after it published images he had altered.